10 Ways to Modernize an Old Home—Without Erasing Its Character
There’s nothing like the charm of an old house: original wood floors, unique built-ins, stories in every corner. In the Minneapolis, that charm runs deep—the median home age is about 75 years old. Of course, with that vintage beauty often come tricky layouts, drafty windows and a long list of repairs. The key to a successful old home renovation? Making thoughtful upgrades that improve how your home functions and feels—without compromising the things that make it special.
Most people don’t want to live in a museum, but they’re also not sure how to bring in modern updates without messing with the magic. That’s where a little strategy—and a lot of respect for the original details—goes a long way.
At Tusk, we believe your home’s history and future can coexist. Whether you’re planning a full remodel or just refreshing one room, here are our go-to tips for renovating an old house while celebrating (and leaning into) its character.
1. Understand What Makes Your Home Unique
Before diving into renovations, take a moment to really notice what makes your home special. Is it the original wood trim that frames every room? The stained-glass windows that catch the light just right? A fireplace with years of stories built into its bricks? Or maybe vintage tilework that adds a splash of color? Knowing what’s worth protecting will guide design decisions and ensure you don’t accidentally strip away the charm you fell in love with.
If your home has been renovated by a previous owner, there also might be some “unique” changes and features that you want to undo. If that’s the case, check out a few home listings and open houses of similar houses in your city to collect ideas for layout, design and features that would’ve been original to yours—and the ways others have updated these spaces over the years. We like to think about updates in a way that feels cohesive with the rest of the home: it’s new, but it’s as if it was always meant to be there.
2. Keep Original Woodwork and Trim Whenever Possible
In many pre-1970s homes, the wood trim wasn’t mass-produced; it was custom-crafted for the space. That kind of detail is hard (and expensive) to replicate today. Whenever possible, restore and refinish original baseboards, crown molding, window casings and door frames instead of replacing them. If pieces are too damaged or missing, a skilled carpenter can match the species, profile and proportions to blend old and new seamlessly.
3. Restore or Repurpose Vintage Built-Ins
Built-in cabinets, bookcases, hutches and window seats aren’t just functional—they’re full of personality. If they’re looking rough, refinishing or repainting will go a long way. You can also reimagine their purpose: turn an old buffet into a bar, add a coffee station to a butler’s pantry, or transform a window seat nook into a cozy reading spot with added cushions and lighting.
4. Match or Replicate Historic Fixtures and Hardware
An aged brass doorknob worn smooth by decades of use, a creaky-but-beautiful hinge that’s been there longer than any of us—these small elements add up to a home that feels storied and soulful.
If you’re lucky enough to have originals, consider them treasures worth saving. If not, architectural salvage shops in your area are likely to have hardware that will feel right for your house (we love Architectural Antiques in Northeast Minneapolis).
If you need to buy new, you can also find era-appropriate reproductions out there from specialty suppliers. Coordinating finishes and styles throughout your home helps everything feel intentional and cohesive, keeping that old-house charm intact right down to the doorknobs.
5. Maintain or Recreate Original Flooring Patterns and Materials
Original hardwood floors bring serious character, but not all can be saved. If your flooring is in decent shape, refinishing can restore its warmth and depth. Even worn or uneven boards can often be salvaged with a good sanding and a durable finish.
If boards are too damaged or there's patchy replacement work from past renovations, replacing with wood in a similar species, width and finish can preserve the look. For tile, you can often replicate historic mosaic patterns using modern materials that nod to the original style.
When in doubt, keep it consistent across visible areas—continuity in flooring goes a long way.
6. Open (or Not) Thoughtfully
Older homes often follow a different logic than today’s open floor plans, but that doesn’t mean you should blow out every wall (some houses are just meant to have rooms!).
If you’re craving more connection, consider strategic tweaks that preserve your home’s original charm. Widen doorways to improve flow, create new sightlines between rooms or partially open shared spaces while keeping key features like archways, niche walls and ceiling medallions intact. Often, it’s the original rhythm of a home—the way rooms connect, the proportions, the quirky transitions—that gives it character. Maintaining proportions and transitions where it makes sense can help your home feel authentic, even as you adapt it for modern life.
7. Use Era-Appropriate Paint Colors and Finishes
Color is one of the easiest ways to reinforce a home’s age and style. Research historic palettes from the time your home was built, or work with a designer (hi!) with experience in vintage homes.
Use matte or eggshell finishes to mimic the soft, light-absorbing surfaces found in vintage interiors. And consider natural finishes like milk paint, Marmorino plaster or limewash for added authenticity and texture if that’s right for the age of your home.
Wallpaper is another great way to nod to the history of your home—there are prints and patterns for every decade.
8. Upgrade Systems Discreetly
Yes, you’ll likely need to update plumbing, electrical and HVAC—but thoughtful integration makes all the difference. The best time to tackle these upgrades is when the walls are already open during a reno, and an expert remodeler can help you seamlessly fold new systems into the old bones. Run new wiring behind trim, conceal ductwork in closets, and choose vent covers or switch plates that suit your home’s style. A vintage house can be a smart house!
9. Incorporate Modern Conveniences With Care
Most of our clients don’t want to live in a time capsule—but they’re not always sure how to bring in modern comforts without disrupting the character they love. The key is to weave in upgrades in ways that feel subtle, thoughtful and in tune with the home’s vibe.
Look for appliances with classic styling—a stove with vintage-inspired knobs, or a fridge with a clean, simple design. And for tech, keep it low-key: hide wiring inside walls, tuck speakers into built-ins or use sleek, minimalist controls.
10. Work With Pros Who Know Old Homes
Restoring and remodeling a vintage home takes more than just skill—it takes patience, care and a deep appreciation for how these places were built. At Tusk, we specialize in older homes because we love the stories they hold—and the challenge of helping them live on. Whether you’re renovating for comfort, function or energy efficiency, we’ll help you do it in a way that honors your home’s history and personality.
Love your old house, but ready to make it work better for you? That’s kind of our thing. Learn more about our design-build services.